Varsity Baseball plays a well-rounded schedule of about 35 games, consisting of 18 MIAA 'A' Conference games and multiple games versus highly ranked non-conference teams. The team also travels out of state on occassion and competes against schools from other states. The Dons have qualified for the playoffs in six of the past eight seasons, having won at least one game in each of those six playoff series, and often advancing far into the playoff format. During the 2013 season, the team set a school record with 23 wins. In 2017, the team won its first championship in 71 years. Last year, they made it to the semifinals. Many baseball student-athletes have gone on to play at the Division I, II, and III schools at the collegiate level including Clemson University, Johns Hopkins University, Oberlin College, Towson University, University of Mount Olive, USC–Aiken, and Wheeling Jesuit University.